foreverlabeled (original poster member #52070) posted at 5:47 PM on Friday, May 15th, 2026
I'm back... once again wishing I wasn't here posting about being a shit person. A 20-year-old ghost just appeared, and both my 19-year-old self and my present self are completely consumed by shame and remorse.
I received a message from a woman asking if I had been intimate with her then-boyfriend, now-husband, two decades ago.
Goddammit..
I chose to be completely honest and forthcoming. But in doing the right thing, I just exposed a 20-year lie to a woman who built her entire life on quicksand. Now, that quicksand is engulfing her. My heart is so heavy for her, and my stomach is in knots. It is a pain I would wish on no one.
Years ago, when I was working through my recovery and making amends, I actually tried to find her for this exact reason. I wanted everything out in the light.. no surprises, no more lies, no stones unturned. I wanted to purge the secrets. But because it was a hookup from a decade prior, I didn't have enough information to track her down.
It doesn't matter now; she knows.
There is some relief in knowing that absolutely nothing is left hiding in the shadows anymore. But I am finding it incredibly difficult to cope with the gravity of the bomb I just dropped. It feels like D-Day all over again, and there is carnage everywhere. It is a gut-wrenching, heavy feeling.
I'm just trying to navigate the wreckage of a past I thought was long lost.
Pippin ( member #66219) posted at 5:52 PM on Friday, May 15th, 2026
Hang in there ForeverLabeled, and be kind to yourself. I know the gut punch of realizing there’s a person out there with good reason to despise you and/or you are the reason her life is imploding. It sucks, but probably for a limited time, and it’s much better than the alternative (life of hiding, lying, and shame). Your 19year old self is not your current self even though you are to some extent still cleaning up her messes. I know you have developed good skills for tolerating the negative/uncomfortable emotions. I can’t remember if you are Christian, but if you are, there is a ton of reassurance and solid ground in knowing that you are under the wing of the truth, and you can pray for her.
Him: Shadowfax1
Reconciled for 6 years
Dona nobis pacem
Unhinged ( member #47977) posted at 7:15 PM on Friday, May 15th, 2026
You're not a shit person. Knock that shit off right now!
You told the truth and that, dear lady, is the best thing you could have possibly done.
I wish I had something else to say, something wise and wonderful. I'm sorry you have to work through these feelings of shame and remorse, again. You've been there and done that before, so I'm sure it's familiar ground, however terribly uncomfortable.
It was 20 years ago and I know how hard you've worked on yourself. You've grown, you've learned, you've changed, and you've been an inspiration to a great many people here, including me.
Be gentle with yourself.
[This message edited by Unhinged at 7:16 PM, Friday, May 15th]
Married 2005
D-Day April, 2015
Divorced May, 2022
"The Universe is not short on wake-up calls. We're just quick to hit the snooze button." -Brene Brown
foreverlabeled (original poster member #52070) posted at 8:56 PM on Friday, May 15th, 2026
Hiya Pippin, hiya Unhinged.
Ah yes... be kind to myself. I haven't gotten there yet.
Right now, I'm just consumed with the damage and the pain that is filling her heart today. I keep telling myself to breathe, but my body is flooded with adrenaline and my nervous system is completely shot. I want to crawl under a rock and I can only imagine how much worse she feels.
I’m feeling in total crisis, overwhelmed, and panicked. I've chosen to stay open to her if she needs any further clarification, and waiting for that is all-consuming in its own right.
The shame is incredibly loud right now, and every tool I know feels entirely out of reach.
BearlyBreathing ( member #55075) posted at 9:22 PM on Friday, May 15th, 2026
You gave her back her agency. That is a gift to her, even though she doesn’t see that yet.
She will in time.
We can’t undo what has been done, but we can go forward with honesty and compassion and empathy, and you are doing that. You are not your 19 year old self. You are doing better. You are better.
Feel regret, but also know that you are moving forward with integrity and kindness.
Me: BS 57 (49 on d-day)Him: *who cares ;-) *. D-Day 8/15/2016 LTA. Kinda liking my new life :-)
**horrible typist, lots of edits to correct. :-/ **
AnnieOakley ( member #13332) posted at 12:23 AM on Saturday, May 16th, 2026
You did the right thing in giving her the truth. And it sounds like you have offered more info if she chooses.
Did you know that he was in a relationship? If so, did you acknowledge this to her?
Did you give a sincere apology? Did you offer that you tried to find her years ago?
I can only imagine your shame. I hope that giving her the truth helps a bit more in healing the 19yo and you today.
Me= BSHim=xWH (did the work & became the man I always thought he was, but it was too late)M=23+,T=27+dday=7/06, 8/09 (pics at a work function), 11/09 VAR, 6/12 Sep'd, 10/14 Divorced."If you are going through hell, keep going."
Abcd89 ( member #82960) posted at 6:13 AM on Saturday, May 16th, 2026
She came to you with a question and you answered honestly, and left the door open for further questions. She may have been scared before she asked, maybe she expected you to lie. You didn’t.
I am sure you are very different now to how you were at 19 (you have just demonstrated it).
You are living by your values. You answered honestly. She has agency now and maybe there is more to this than just that question. Maybe she had other suspicions and needed proof. Unless she told you her story honestly and openly (unlikely) then she may be devastated or appreciative of the evidence.
I just found something out about my cheaty spouse and it was a relief (awful information, I should have been devastated but I didn’t even cry) it felt like a weight had been lifted.
You can’t go over it, you can’t go under it, you have got to go through it. Michael Rosen was talking about Bear Hunts but it’s relevant to cheating toads too.
WoodThrush2 ( member #85057) posted at 12:19 PM on Saturday, May 16th, 2026
You did the right thing, thank you so much. Of course it will hurt. It is ugly. As a human get closer and closer to the light....as a human BECOMES more upright...the MORE they will hate and what they did and who they were in the darkness.
Let this only strengthen your resolve to be a promoter of loyalty, honesty, and faithfulness. ❤️🙏
sisoon ( Moderator #31240) posted at 3:20 PM on Saturday, May 16th, 2026
IMO, to heal, one has to take responsibility for themself, and they have to be honest. That's exactly what you did.
Empathy for the BS is another plus for you.
And 19 year olds are not known for prudence. They're known for trying things out, even things that mature adults don't do.
Besides ... exactly how did this play out when you were 19? Did the guy have a choice at the time? Did you really use your feminine wiles to force him to give up his integrity? Or was he perhaps a full participant?
My guess is that OBS is going through hell on earth right now, and I'd bet that your answer shattered one of her significant illusions. Counter-intuitive it may be, but I think you helped her. I may be projecting here, but when I ask a question, I want an honest answer.
Sometimes, doing a right thing hurts - but not as much as doing a wrong thing.
You did well, IMO.
fBH (me) - on d-day: 66, Married 43, together 45, same sex ap
d-day - 12/22/2010 Recover'd and R'ed
You don't have to like your boundaries. You just have to set and enforce them.
thatwilldo ( member #59326) posted at 6:40 PM on Saturday, May 16th, 2026
(((Foreverlabeled)))
When I joined SI in 2017, you were one of the first people to help me...and I needed so much help.
I'm so sorry that you're suffering today. You did the right thing and you're an example to all of us.
To me, you're an inspiration. She will suffer, but will be better off with the truth.
Don't do as I did. Do as I say.
No private messages