The beauty of human behavior is how few absolutes there are.
For most of us reading (no... let’s be honest: for ALL of us reading) your posts we aren’t optimistic about your future if you go the path you seem to be headed. But there are no absolutes, and you might be the exception that proves the rule.
I have a friend who work(ed) in admissions in a prestigious university. His role was to number-crunch and evaluate statistical data about applicants. He once shared with me that they could predict the performance of students with remarkable accuracy – down to individual courses – simply based on collective data. They used this info to select applicants and allocate scholarships. He said that at the start of school they could already predict with accuracy who would drop out in the first months, and who would struggle. They used this info also to offer assistance beforehand, thereby beating their own predictions and lowering the predicted drop-out/failure rate.
He also told me that there were always exceptions... that student who barely made entrance but outshined all others.
Like he said – and I’m repeating – There are few absolutes in human behavior.
This is why I worry for you. You are expecting a positive result without adhering to the collective experience. You are hoping you are the below-average applicant that barely makes entry, yet graduate as valedictorian.
It can happen...
But I want you to keep the following in mind:
In my last post I emphazised:
At some point you need to feel safe and comfortable about that you know the truth OR that you know the truth to a level you are OK with OR that you will never know the truth.
Are you comfortable?
I hope you are, and I can’t refute that MAYBE what you have is enough for you.
I am such a strong believer of marriage. I think it’s the MOST IMPORTANT union we willingly enter and stay in. Some argue that being a parent is more important, and yes – I guess I would save my kids before my wife from a burning building. But parenthood roles change over time, whereas the intimacy and dependency of marriage increases. If all things work out then either one of you will be holding the hands of the other at that final moment, assuring them they have lived a good life, are loved, will be missed, but can allow themselves to drift off.
At that time – be it having my hand held or me holding her hand – I don’t want to leave with any unanswered questions.
What concerns me about your story and last posts are these issues:
Self-blame. Your actions being a logical reason for her to have decided she should seek some form of solace with another man.
This is like you explaining to us how her putting a bullet in your head was a reasonable reaction to your bad breath. After all – you snacked daily on raw fish and onions. Definite cause for her do talk about things, demand change and all that. But never reason enough to head for the gun-safe...
It’s OK to discuss how your actions caused breaches in the marriage, but at the same time it’s important to lay ground-rules on how to deal with that.
What might happen a couple of years down the road when you forget to put your used coffee-mug in the sink for the fifth day in a row? Would that justify her snuggling the delivery-guy?
Lack of trust... This is big IMHO. Trust is the first thing out the window on d-day. Takes a lot of time to rebuild a realistic form of trust. The blind-trust of yore should be gone forever. It’s a trust-but-verify process, that once been verified enough turns into a verifiable trust.
While your wife is hiding something that happened during her affair... she isn’t trusting you.
I find her reaction at the poly extremely suspect. I think something happened with OM that she isn’t sharing. It might be as "innocent" as making out, a peck on the cheek, inuendo... or it could have been a planned date never carried through... or it could be a secret afternoon going at it like apes in heat. We don’t know. You don’t know.
What happened is not the key-issue. What is the key-issue is that you don’t know if you have the truth or not.
This brings me back to my key-question:
At some point you need to feel safe and comfortable about that you know the truth OR that you know the truth to a level you are OK with OR that you will never know the truth.
Are you comfortable?
Don’t have to answer us, but I do think you deserve it to yourself to answer YOU.