Hi Eryn,
"Welcome" here, even if noone dreams of joining the BS side, I know you are hurting a lot, the 'good news' is you will feel better and become stronger, with time and the correct actions you will be able to rebuild what is now your shattered self.
He asked to come over Valentines day because we needed to talk
Sharing misfortunes might make you feel less lonely, I have found out 2 Days before Valentine's day. Difference is I found out the lie alone, she did not confessed it, and that was DDay#3.
I get how you feel.
Now few things about your Wayward Partner and you. To give you some structure to the chaos of emotions you are feeling, it will hopefully make you feel less lost:
During july-sept he and a joint friend (F) pushed friendship to a line that was not comfortable, messaging all the time, spending alot of time together and as stupid amount of X's at the end of both of their messages. I adressed it with him and he cut her out of his life as did i and was assured it was platonic nothing more by them both.
Be always very wary of "friendship" between a woman and a man.
While it is not impossible to have a friend of the opposite sex (if you are heterosexual), it is always "conditional".
- Is possible if the other woman is your friend (or a close common friend of both)
- If she is a childhood connection
- If she is gay
- If she is related to you
- If she is related to him
- If he meets her with you or in social settings (if they meet more than a few times alone, exceptionally, that's leaning into dating)
- Absolute and complete transparency with you
This are examples where a man and a woman can genuinely be friends. And sometimes sex still happens (even with your 'friends' or sisters, is just the way it is).
Your red flags and alarm bells told you already everything you knew, so it's no surprise there, you were not controlling, your jealousy was natural because you spotted danger, sometimes when you see the truck racing at you it truly means is going to hit you in the face.
The thing to learn to understand relationship tiers with others is called "boundaries". When even one is crossed, that's where is no longer 'friendship' (appropriate) and becomes 'sexual attraction'(inappropriate).
Each boundary crossed makes the next one easier to cross. Sex is just few boundaries away from "inappropriate".
Defend your and the bond's boundaries, always.
He should have never left, he missed us, our family and me and he wanted to come home. Ok not what I was expecting so I threw my arms around him because for 7 months that is what I had wanted to hear but he told me to not hug him, that he wantes to lay all the cards out and be transparently honest and open. Confused is an understatement now.
This is not a bad sign.
Of course is bad and the 'unthinkable' trauma happened.
But this signals regret, if not yet guilt. It's important that he came clean instead of you finding out, it means he "owns it" and takes accountability (at least partially), which is the critical starting point for a wayward partner if they are ever going to put in the work to change their character flaw.
It hurts because he lied, because he cheated, because he replaced you with the OW, but he realized it was not about you or the OW, it was about himself and his flaws, and he fucked up your life for his stupidity.
So it's painful, but is a good start, many of us never get a spontaneous confession, we get lies and have to find out on our own.
He lied but he came clean.
Bad, but somewhat "better".
Days before our anniversary (which is in Nov) they kissed, then at the end of Nov they slept together. He was staying there almost every night and started to sleep in the OW bed. This lasted through Dec and into early Jan.
--cut--
He never loved her, he had no feelings for her, the sex was aweful, he couldn't perform and he knew he had made the biggest mistake of his life, the OW wanted more and wanted to tell me, which according to him was one of the wake up calls that, that wasnt the life he wanted. They never went on a date, never snuggled and never cuddled in bed or after sex or to go to sleep. Like I said I asked alot of questions some of which I didnt want to know but knew I needed to.
Right now, be wary of a thing called "trickle truths". He might not be malicious, he might genuinely see your pain and have an ambivalent desire to clear his dirty conscience and at the same time telling you an "edulcorated - edited" version of the truth that you can take, with the idea that will hurt you less than the full unedited truth.
Well it does not, it mixes lies into a confession, it will "eyedrop" the pain in different moments, so you don't get the full blast now, but it also ensures in the future you will find the lies (they never stay hidden forever, weeks, months, years, decades.... they always come out in the end if you both live) and it will hit you again with the full force of what you are feeling now, right when you thought you were healing.
He thinks he is sparing you pain, he is not. He is ensuring a longer period of suffering for you. Just mentioning this is what goes through the mind of many wayward partners, is natural, not evil, but hell is paved with good intentions and you are having a rollercoaster ride through the abyss right now.
So, not to be hard with you but just to prepare you to not feel the carpet swept under your feet again, understand this is the purpose.
I am a guy, some things really sounds.... unlikely.
Here is what seems to check out and what doesn't:
- He never loved her. Possible. Even likely. She was a replacement of you for a void he felt. She might have been just a body to keep him warm while he missed you, but she was easier and less complicated to approach than to approach the solution to your relationship problems (likely his character flaws, often low self worth, people pleasing, avoidance, compartmentalization).
A man can have sex with a woman feeling next to nothing at all.
This is usually difficult to understand for women (some do but is pretty rare), because you need emotional connection and safety to let go physically.
But it is usually this way, think of prostitution. You have not "zero feelings" but they are so mild that is like you have nothing at all for this woman. Feeling usually develop with time, intimacy and connection (in this kind of relationships) and if he did not start with feeling connected, it is very unlikely to reach the level that you call "love" like you had in your relationship.
From his reaction in confessing, I'd say likely, he did not love her. He used her for comfort.
- the sex was aweful, he couldn't perform and he knew he had made the biggest mistake of his life possibly it was bad, it happens, and in some cases we still go back to that woman because "better than nothing". But it depends, how long did they have this sexual encounters? I understand almost daily for quite a while. If it was truly that bad he'd go there just to release the urge, not daily. It might be but consider it might not be the whole truth.
That he made the biggest mistake of his life. Yeah he did. And maybe this will be a turning point for him as it was for you, you were left with no choice due to his terrible choices. Now he has a choice to change, to allow you to heal from this trauma.
You paid his decision with unspeakable pain. He paid it with a piece of his soul, and that'll never come back.
He might finally be seeing it.
the OW wanted more and wanted to tell me, which according to him was one of the wake up calls that, that wasnt the life he wanted.
Of course she did. The OW is usually a lower value female than the Betrayed Partner. He chose her not because she is better, but because she is available and dirty enough to mingle with a man in a relationship (the Affair Partners are having issues as the Wayward Partners if not way worse, that's why they are happy to roll in the mud, because they feel better than they are, and also they feel "better than you" as they are "chosen" as your replacement. Is twisted and a lot to unpack, so let's leave it at that). You will hear here something like "they always affair down" meaning they always choose a worse partner than the partner they betray.
Or else, they would break up and become more selective for the next relationship. Cheating is not an upgrade, is a fall in the mud.
The "wake up call" might be both "a genuine realization", or "damage control", telling you before she does. I do not know what is the case, but be careful.
He is showing some signals of remorse and shame, but you need to understand this: Your Partner can lie. He lied to you a lot, he is a liar. Take whatever he says with a pinch of salt. He might learn to stop lying, but it will not be a killswitch, is part of his character flaw. Just preparing you not to cling to hope or fantasy, you need to detach from those, for your own protection.
They never went on a date, never snuggled and never cuddled in bed or after sex or to go to sleep.
I am calling bullshit on this. They might not have been "on a date" as an official couple (more by fear of being found out and you getting to know than anything elase, because surely they enjoyed spending time together).
The second part is a lie. Not that you need to desire to be warm and cuddle with a woman you keep just for sex, but it's always "the price to pay" to be sure there is a 'next time'.
You have sex with a woman, you hold her because after she will be close to you and expect this. Unless you want to make clear there is not going to be a next time, if that's the case, you dress up, say bye and cross the door blocking her number and making sure she will not contact you again.
He was in the first category, not the second.
Sorry Eryn, I know I am being harsh, but do not believe everything or cling to fantasy, this is not a fairy tale anymore, is hell, and acknowledging it will help you climbing up from this abyss faster.
I caught a family photo we have on the wall, I saw our children, saw the home we have built, the past 11 years and the love I still felt for him.
I made the decision to try, to rebuild.
Means your attachment is healthy, now is deeply wounded, but what you feel is normal in a healthy attached woman.
Your feeling are normal, he mattered for you, you want to restore what was broken.
Just know this: the relationship is dead. What was before can never come back. Betrayal killed it all. Right now there is no past, no present, no future for the old relationship.
You can never rebuild.
You can only build something new.
And to do that, this is the most important step to take before anything else:
- The BS heals the BS
- The WS heals the WS
Only after healing you can start truly rebuilding, which means reclaiming connection and rebuilding trust, one day at a time.
Do not miss this step, is the foundation to Reconciliation.
I was speechless, which takes alot, I felt everything and nothing at the same time, i was silent for what felt like an eternity, i had so much going through my head but not a single sound would come out, not a sinhle tear fell it was just silence.
This is called Betrayal Trauma. It's normal you feel this way.
This is not emotional like an heartbreak, it is mental, physical, emotional, identity and reality shattering. Is among the deepest abuse a human being could ever experience, is not a figure of speech, is in the top echelon of those.
Is what you need to heal because it can turn into PTSD, and destroy every aspect of your life for decades.
Therapy and Individual Counseling with a good specialist will help you to heal this wound.
Talking and making sense of the chaos you feel here can also help you, but you need therapy.
Take it from a guy who faced it alone and paid the price for 17 years.
I can't be intimate with him because it isn't safe, it took me a few days but I finally was able to kiss him and I can share a bed with him, the whole time he reassured, didnt preassure and we talked through everything.
Perfectly normal, you must feel safe for that, you need to restore your emotional connection at least in part before connecting physically. Is a bit the opposite of what happened to betrayed husbands, physical connection to rebuild emotional.
That should come back as long as you rebuild trust.
One word of warning: watch for "the ick" if that happens in the future you need to treat it in therapy.
It does not happen always, but sometimes the betrayed partner develops physical disgust for the body of the Wayward partner.
It happened to me, I wanted to vomit every time we got intimate, and it just got worse with the years, to the point I did not wanted to touch her, kiss her, have sex with her, because it was repulsive.
I did it out of duty, and hated it and myself for what I felt.
Hopefully is not the case, but a red flag to watch for in the path of healing, it can show up immediately or years later. It can go away, but sometimes it is permanent if not addressed, and in that case there is no coming back from that.
My sister hates him but she also is almost punishing me for making the decision to not kick him to the curb, telling me I have made a mistake.
Understandable, the healthiest way to heal from betrayal is to end the relationship and root out the cheater from your life, memories, worries. Like they never existed.
However, you still love him. And that's deeply human.
Your sister cares for you, but she should understand that you made a choice to give a second chance.
This is not weak, this is brave.
And she must respect it, no matter if she can't understand it right now, is none of her business.
she can support you, not criticize your choices.
I have not been able to go into our town because the OW works there.
She was already capable of ruining your life by stealing your man.
Don't give her any more agency.
Just how much power and influence over your life you want to give to a worm?
She is not worthy.
You are.
Live your life, heads up, she will live in the mud, you will leave above ground.
I can't be intimate with him again and I feel like I should be preparing myself for the other shoe to drop but he has said this is where he wants to be and even mentioned marriage (which i told him to propose now would be stupid but it made me smile).
I just want to feel normal for one minute.
It can go either way, but the most important thing for you is to find clarity now.
You must heal yourself. Share here, get advice from those who have been there where you are now.
Find a good counselor for IC.
Read the articles here and the healing library.
The BS heals the BS. That's when you will feel noraml again, and not just for a minute.
And the WS must heal the WS, for a true R to have even a chance to begin.
I can see light at the end of th tunnel and it's closer than it was. I want to not think about it anymore, I want to trust him.
It is really too fresh for seeing the light at the end of the tunnel. Right now you are in shock, then it will come anger, then sadness, then anger, grief, detachment, and only in the end you will have stability. Only if you start the healing process, or you risk to become stuck somewhere in a feedback loop (trust me, talking from personal experience, don't do my mistake)
Do not face this alone Eryn, you will find help, and you will raise to be yourself again, I can promise you that.
Your man might even rise above the person he was before, if he put in the work he can.
Last, the most important thing you need is not to hear "it's ok" or "it will be ok". Right now it is just "not ok".
You simply need to be heard.
You have been heard.
[This message edited by BackfromtheStorm at 9:58 AM, Tuesday, February 24th]